How does Saussure’s linguistic sign work?
unites: concept + sound image
(signified + signifier)
there is an arbitrary connection (not natural), governed by convention
if there WAS a natural connection, different languages couldn’t have different names for things
What are exceptions to the arbitrariness of the linguistic sign?
onomatopoeia
symbols (there is a connection beween signified + signifier, if not natural it is historical)
-> stylized fish “ichtys” is an acronym of ancient greek (no arbitrary connection)
What is the linear nature of the signifier?
“in contrast to visual signifiers which can offer simultaneous groupings, auditory signifiers have at their present command only the dimension of time. Their elements are presented in succession, they form a chain”
-> texts can’t be taken in all at once, a picture CAN be recognized immediately
What is the referent?
The object in the real world, represented by the lingustic sign
What are referent, signified and signifier in the pipe painting by Magritte?
referent: pipe irl
signifier: painting AND the word
signified: concept of a pipe
Of what does the 1. system consist?
signifier
signified
sign (meaning)
Who was Roland Barthes?
lived from 1915-1980
french essayist, social critic
helped establish semiotics
chair of literary semiology at Collège de France
died in bus accident
posthumously outed as gay
What is Roland Barthes most famous for?
his book “S/Z”, a model analysis of a short story by Balzac (dissects codes present in literary texts)
book “mythologies” seeks to uncover assumptions behind objects of popular culture
investigated (non-)language-based sign systems (fashion, sports, ads, …)
What is Roland Barthes’ definiton of “myth”?
a type of speech, a system of communication chosen by history (= cannot evolve from “the nature of things”)
myth are “models of writing and representation” (film, photos,…)
NOT an object, concept, idea
What is mythology?
the study of a type of speech
both a part of semiolog as much as it is a formal science/historical science
What is another definition of myth that establishes it as a metalangue?
“myth is a peculiar system, in that it is constructed from a semiological chain which existed before it: it is a second-order semiological system.
That which is a sign in the first system, becomes a mere signifier in the second system”
What is the first system? And what the second?
language
myth
How is the sign (meaning) transformed from 1. to 2. system?
goes from sign (meaning) to the 2. signifier, called FORM
What is the signifier called in the 2. system?
form
What is the signified called in the 2. system?
concept
What is the FORM (sign/meaning level 1, signifier level 2) of the cover of Paris Match?
a black boy, dressed in an uniform, eyes lifted to something off-screen, giving french salute
What is the sign called in the 2. system?
signification
What is the CONCEPT (signified level 2) on the cover of Paris Match?
(positive reading)
France is a great empire
there is no racial discrimination
criticism of colonialism is wrong
ex-colonised serve of their own free will
(negative reading)
France is using people who can’t object to fight its colonial wars
calling a war “the events” makes it sound harmless/trivial
What are the 3 types of semiotic exchange?
indication
communication
How is indication defined?
the receiver judges the context and decides to read something as an index of something else
How is signification defined (as semiotic exchange)?
the receiver shares a code with the producer of a sign and can decipher to which signified is linked
How is communication defined?
a sender produces a message with the intenion of having it heard/read AND understood by a receiver
What is an example for communication?
The nautical sign “Lima”
stands for both the letter L and “stop your vessel immediately” or “quarantined ship”
Why can myth be described as “interpellant speech”?
because it addresses you directly as a subject, it invites you
What does Barthes say about myth and its innocence?
myth is the vehicle of ideology but does everything to avoid being seen as such
makes itself look neutral and innocent
it is histor, but wants to appear as nature
What is the essential function of a myth?
the naturalization of a concept
it distorts and sells the cultural as natural
How do politicians use myth?
by claiming that something is natural because it has always been that way
implies therefore that something ELSE is unnatural and dangerous
What is the relationship between myth and history?
the world supplies historical reality, myth gives a “natural image” of this reality, things lose the memory that they once were made
myth has tunred reality inside out, emptied it of history and filled it with nature
Which hidden set of rules/codes/conventions render a specific social group universal for the whole society?
rhethoric of common sense
naturalisation
ideological core od diverse cultural practices
looking for “the invisible seam between language, experience and reality” -> prising it open through semiotic analysis
Who was Pierre Poujade and why was Barthes worried in his observation?
leader of an anti-intellectual, racist, populist political party
- a forerunner of the front national
What are myths today/ tautologies we can’t see, to outgrow?
(to Barthes times; business is business)
today: trumpism, tea party, brexit is brexit
Last changed2 years ago