Death Denial
Ignording or suppressing the thougth of death, including any associated anxiety
common defense mechanism and coping strategy whereby one pushes something out of consciousness
Death Acceptance
A “giving in” and realizing of the inevitablity of death
being psychologically prepard for the final exit
both cognitive and emotional
Approach-Oriented Death Acceptance
People with this attitude feel truly positive about death and may even look forward to its occurrence
I've lived long enough, and I don't want to have my life extended. I know it'sawful, but I'd like to go to sleep and not wake up. I know that's a shock to thefamily, but it's great for the person concerned.” (Beryl at age 95)
Neutral Death Acceptance
People with this attitude accept the inevitability of death; they neither look forward to it nor fear its occurrence.
“Life in prison isn't a life, this isn't living, man. It's just surviving.”“If people say they're going to kill me, get to it.”
Escape-Oriented Death Acceptance
People with this attitude welcome theend of life and view death as an escapefrom pain and suffering
“If I go through with it, I die, as I must at some point. If I don't go through with it, mychoice is essentially to suffer and to inflict suffering on my family, and then die,possibly in a way that is considerably more stressful and painful than this way. I'vegot death. I've got suffering and death. Well gee, you know, this makes a whole lot ofsense to me.”
Death Acceptance by Age (Wong et al. 1994)
Stages of Dying by Kübler-Ross 1969
Denial
Temporary shock resonse in which the person does not believe or accept what is happening
used by nearly all patients in some form
often leads to isolation from friends/family
CAN serve an important function, normal, healthy, adaptive
diagnosis denial in 4-47%, impact denial in 8-70% of cancer patients
may be used as sole defence, or ill or dying people may engage in partial denial
Anger
Feelings of frustration nd resentment
different expressions
can be towards deity, universe, others…
Bargaining
A brief stage involving irrational attempts to postpone death
often involves conversation with deity or universe
difficult to study
“Please God, let me live to see my daughter graduate.”
Depression
Feelings of sadness, despair and helplessness, a grieving over one’s losses and empending death
reactive depression (past losses) - job, hobbies, mobility
Preparator depression (losses to come) - familiy, relationships
Typically the longest stage - many never move onto the next
25-77% incidence rate in terminally ill patients
Acceptance
A “giving in” and realizing of the inevitability of death, often neither happy nor sad, sometimes void of feelings
According to Kübler-Ross,when people are given somehelp with the process, most areable to achieve a peacefulresolution with their lives.
Advantages of Kübler-Ross Model
range of reactions to death, dispelling the myth that there is a single appropriate response
has broken down social/cultural barriers and taboos
allows counsellors to identify needs
Criticism on Kübler-Ross Model
did not consider pre-existing literature
no evidence for order and universality of the 5 stages
may be interpreted as the “right way” to die
Within clinical setting
may be normative, move patients along with goal of acceptance
result in attempts to control/ manage dying process
lead to labelling of some patients as good based on their trajectory —> making others feel guilty
Study on Denial/ Acceptance
Qualitative study
denial and acceptance fluctuate
interdependent coping strategies
denial can serve as temporary safety net to preserve self-esteem, maintain relationships, prevent chaos at certain points in dying process
Evidence that denial is more common early on and acceptance more common closer to death
Three Phase Descriptive model
Pattison 1977: 3 stages of living-dying interval
Acute Phase: Fear and anxiety at peak
Chronic Living-Dying Phase: anxiety reducd, uestions about the unknown are asked, acceptance begins
Terminal Phase: imminent death is finally accepted, person withdraws emotionally and socially
Stages of Death Work
Shnetdman (1980) , levels of death work a person must complete
Psychological: preparing to meet one’s end and coming to terms with dying
Social: enabling oneself to help loved ones in the preparation for their survival
Achieving an Appropriate Death
Weisman & Hackett (1961): Suggested 4 main requirements for the person dying:
Reduction of conflicts (inner & outer)
Compatibility with ego ideal
Continuity of relationships is preserved & restored
Fulfilment of prevailing wishes
Given a little choice and autonomy, what death would be bestfor us, the death most consistent with the values and aims wehave followed throughout life?” (Weisman)
Edgework
Behaviour that explores the limits of safety and convention, voluntary risk-taking
involves material practices (doings), embodied experiences (sensations), supporting structures
danger, excitement and control are key
Used to analyze:
academic career risk-taking
extreme ritual performances
negotiating violent domestic relationships
pro-anorexia subculture —-
Near-Death Experience
NDEs involve a variety of sensations reported by people who have died and been brought back to life, and by people who have come close to death
hearing someone pronounce them dead
feelings of peace
travelling through a dark space or tunnel
seeing a review of their life
8% of Americans have died and regained consciousness or come close to death, 35% of those reported NDEs
Criss-Cultural evidence of NDEs (5-48% of adults and 85% of childen )
Physiological Explanation of NDEs
Brain dos not shut down as quickly when heart stops beating
hyper state of perceptual neural activity
Brain regions: Amygdala, Hippocampus, Cortex
NDEs are very similar to drug-induced hallucinations, but not identical
Ketamine most similar, followed by psychedelics
Psychological Effects of NDEs
Most NDEs have a significant positive and lasting impact
new sense of meaning & purpose
loss of fear of death
new or renewed belief in afterlife
new sense of self, increased self-esteem
more open, caring and loving
Reminiscence & Life Review
Reminiscence – Volitional and non-volitional act of recollectingmemories of one’s self in the past (Bluck & Levine, 1998).
Some functions are maladaptive (Cappeliez & O’Rourke, 2006).In a study of nursing home residents, a reminiscence groupdemonstrated improvements in depression and loneliness aftersharing memories, life events, family history, and personalaccomplishments (Franck et al., 2016).
Life Review – Return of memories and past conflicts at end of life;spontaneous or structured evaluation/reconciliation of one’s life
Symbolic Immortality
A sense of continuity or immortality obtained through symbolic means, five modes
Biological (genetic means, children)
Creative (arts, teaching, mentoring)
Transcendental (spiritual, religious beliefs)
Natural (sense of connectedness to nature/ earth)
Experiential transcendences (psychich state - one so intense and all-encompassing that time and death disappear)
Correlated with purpose in life and reduced fear of death
Not only dies symbolic immortality give life meaning, if also ensures our continued symbolic connection to others after we dies
Generativity (Erikson)
Guiding the next generation (vs. stagnation)
Involves generative concern for next generation, resulting from social/ cultural pressures as well as internal desires for symbolic immortality
in old age, continuing generative concern is partly dependent on the attitudes and respect of younger generations
guiding, giving back, making a difference, taking care
Religion and Spirituality
Religiosity: Endorsing or subscribing to an organized system of beliefs, practices, rituals and symbols
Extrinsic ( self-serving, external) and intrinsic (Meaning-based and altruistic)
Large amount of research suggests that only intrinsic religiosity is significantly related to meaning in life
Spirituality: A “personal quest for understanding answers toultimate questions about life, about meaning, and aboutrelationship to the sacred or transcendent”
Physical Ilness and suicide
Highest risk in traumatic brain injuries, sleep disorders and HIV, 17 conditions were associated with increased risk
Suicidal Ideation/ Suicidal Thoughts
Thinking about, considering or planning suicide
Risk factor for suicide, but most people who have suicidal thoughts do not attempt suicide
Factors in Suicidal Ideation
Mental Illness
Other pssych factors (gried, isoltion)
Life Events (incl. ilness)
Gender
Age (highest rates in middle-aged men and women (35 to 59) and older men (60+)
Ethnicity, minority status and income elvel
Last changeda year ago