Buffl

Geochemie

as
by alexis S.



Metabolism First Hypothesis

metabolic networks (self-sustaining chemical cycles) emerged before genetic replication => Life began with autocalytic cycles that could grow and evolve


  • IRON SULFUR WORLD HYPOTHESIS (at black smokers)

    • life began with autocatalytic metabolic cycles on mineral surfaces

      -> Iron sulfide (FeS) reacts with CO producing organic molecules and releasing (small amounts) of free energy (that theoretically could promote further biochemical reactions (=early form of metabolism)

PROS:

  • long lasting steady flow of energy

  • because of the chimney like structure of the vents, the organic molecules produced can accumulate locally (and do not have to fill up the entire ocean as assumed by primordial soup hypothesis)

PROBLEMS:

  • Water coming out of the black smokers reaches temperature of 300°C -> would destroy organic molecules

  • IRON SULFUR WORLD HYPOTHESIS (at white smokers)

    (compatible with Top-Down Approach, siehe unten)

    • Alkaline Vents (ex. “lost city”) have

      -> moderate temperatures (70-90°) ideal for organic molecule stability

      -> Due to serpentinization (=> sea water reacts with mineral olvine (contained in Earthcrust) formating serpentine and H2) => High pH (9-11)

    • Natural Proton Gradient: Minerals in white smokers form compartments due to the amotsphere rich in CO2(which partially dissolved in oceans and acidifieds it) leading to compartments with different concentrations

      • Vent fluid: pH 9-11 (highly alkaline, low H+ concentration)

      • Seawater: pH ~6 (more acidic, higher H+ concentration)

        -> difference creates a proton gradient

        => natural protonmotive force (same force that drives ATP Syntehsis!)

        -> inorganic compartments = precursos of cell walls & membranes found in free-living prokaryotes

    • Iron-sulfur minerals at surface of bubbles have catalytic properties & can convert H2 and CO2 to simple organic molecules like methane or acetate.


Connection to Top-Down Approach:

  • LUCA as anaerobic and thermophilic organism that inhabitated a geochemically-active environment

  • LUCA’s Biochemistry: replete with FeS.clusters (transition metal enzymes) that enabnle to live of H2 and fix CO2 and N2

    • Prokaryotic groups identified at base of tree of life (phylogenetic analysis)

      • methanogenic Archaea

      • acetogenic Bacteria

Feature

Alkaline Vent Hypothesis

Classic Iron-Sulfur World

Environment

Serpentinizing vents (pH ~11)

Acidic vents (pH ~3–6)

Energy Source

H₂ + pH gradient

FeS → FeS₂ redox

Key Molecules

H₂, CH₄, formate

CO, H₂S, Fe(CO)₅

Link to Life

Direct proton gradients → ATP analogs

Surface metabolism → peptides


CHALANGES:

  • Link to genetics: doesn’t explain how heredity (e.g. RNA/DNA) emerged from puerly metabolic systems

  • Limited Evolvability: Experiments show that purely metabolic networks struggle to undergo evolution

  • Some reactions (e.g. peptide formation) occur at very low efficiencies




Author

alexis S.

Information

Last changed